returnpass
GuidesSign in
All guides

How to start a loyalty program for a small service business

Decide what the program is for (more repeat visits, or money before the work), pick the format that does that job, set a reward you can afford with some simple maths, offer it at the counter, and check three numbers after a couple of months. Here is each step.

The five steps

  1. Pick one goal. Either regulars come back more often, or customers pay for visits before you do the work.
  2. Pick the format that does that job. A punch card, points, a prepaid package or a membership.
  3. Set the reward and the number of visits. Work out what the reward costs you and how long a good customer takes to earn it.
  4. Tell customers. At the counter, as they pay, every time, by everyone who works there.
  5. Measure it. Note how often regulars come now, then check again after two or three months.

None of this needs software to start. A small service business with one chair, one van or one room can run every step on paper. What a tool adds is the record: who has a card, who is close to a reward, and how many paid visits you still owe.

Step 1: pick one goal

More repeat visits. The customer already likes you. The program gives them a reason to come back sooner, and to come back to you rather than the place down the road. The reward is something you give away, so this costs you a little on every customer who finishes.

Money before the work. The customer pays for several visits at once, usually at a small discount. You have the cash now and their next visits are already decided. You also owe those visits until they are used, which is a debt to your customers, not money you have earned yet.

You can have both, but decide which one matters more, because it decides the format. Is it worth the effort at all? The study usually quoted here is Reichheld and Sasser’s 1990 Harvard Business Review article, which found that cutting the share of customers who leave by 5% raised profits by between 25% and 85% across the businesses studied, and by 30% in an auto-service chain (HBR). You will often see it quoted as “25% to 95%”; the original range stops at 85%. The customer retention guide has the detail.

Step 2: choose the format

Punch card (stamp card). One stamp per visit, a reward after a set number. It is the easiest to explain and to run, and it suits services that cost about the same each time: a cut, a wash, a lesson, a coffee. Its weakness is that a $20 visit and a $200 visit earn the same stamp.

Points. Customers earn points for what they spend and trade them for rewards. It is fairer when spend varies a lot, as in a shop, but it is harder to explain (“how much is a point worth?”) and in practice it needs a till that counts every sale. For most one-person service businesses it is more machinery than the job needs.

Prepaid package. Five washes, ten classes, a season of lawn cuts, paid once at a small discount. It brings money in before you do the work and commits the customer to coming back. The trade-off is documented: research on contract design from UC Berkeley’s Haas School found that paying up front attracts more customers, while paying afterwards tends to get more people to actually finish (Iyer et al.). So a package sells well and can then sit unused. Keep an eye on who has stopped coming. The prepaid packages guide covers pricing and that trade-off.

Membership. A monthly fee for unlimited visits or a set number each month. It gives the steadiest income, but it needs a card on file, recurring billing, and a way to handle cancellations, and it asks a lot of a customer who has only visited twice. It suits businesses people use every week, such as a gym or a car wash with heavy regulars.

If you are unsure, start with a punch card. It is the cheapest to try and the easiest to stop. Add a prepaid package for the customers who ask to pay in advance.

Step 3: choose the reward and the number of visits

What the reward costs you. “Every tenth visit free” gives away one visit in ten, so 10% of the work for card holders who finish. “Buy ten, get the eleventh free” is one in eleven, about 9%. Your real cost is what the free visit costs you to deliver, not its price: on a $40 wash that takes $12 of product and time, the reward costs you $12, not $40.

A smaller reward can work as well as a free visit: an upgrade, an add-on, a longer session. It costs you less and still feels like a gift. Pick something the customer would actually notice.

How many visits. Start from how often a good customer already comes, then decide how far away the reward should feel. Visits per month multiplied by months to the reward gives the stamp count:

Give them a head start. In a field experiment at a car wash, customers given a ten-stamp card with two stamps already filled in finished it 34% of the time; customers given an empty eight-stamp card finished it 19% of the time, though both needed eight more washes for the same reward (Nunes & Drèze). Stamping the first visit when you hand the card over is the simplest way to use this. The punch card guide explains the study.

For a prepaid package, the maths is the single price times the number of visits, less the discount. Five $40 washes at 10% off is $180. Keep the numbers round enough that a customer can check them in their head.

Write the rules down before you start: what earns a stamp (any visit, or only a paid service), whether a card or package expires, and whether it can be shared. Rules on expiry dates for prepaid services differ by province and state, so check yours before you put a date on a package.

Step 4: tell customers

The best moment is at the counter while they pay, because that is when they already intend to come back. One sentence does it: “This is your card; your eighth visit is on us, and today counts.” Then stamp it.

Step 5: measure it

Before you start, write down a baseline: roughly how many regulars you have and how often they come. After two or three months, check three things:

For prepaid packages add two more: how many paid visits you still owe, and which customers are down to their last visit or two, because those are the people to offer another package. Be honest about the limits: no loyalty program can tell you which visits would have happened without it.

How Returnpass does it

Returnpass runs the two formats that suit a small service business: stamp cards and prepaid packages. When you create a package you choose the pass type: Prepaid visits, Loyalty stamps, or Both, where one card carries paid visits and stamps toward a reward and you choose at the counter which a scan spends. You set what counts as one visit, the number of visits or stamps, the reward or the package price, and whether passes expire (never, after a number of days, or on a fixed date).

You issue a pass with the customer’s name and share the link. Your customer keeps it in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, with no app to install. Scan to redeem: tap Scan pass, then Add 1 stamp, Redeem 1 visit or Redeem reward. You can also find a customer by name, or let them scan a code at your counter, which sends a request you approve. Payment for a package is collected the way you take it now; Returnpass never handles that money.

The measuring is built in. The dashboard shows active passes, Prepaid visits remaining and Rewards ready to claim. The owner’s report adds visits redeemed in a period, the value of package visits still owed, and a Ready for a refill list of customers with two or fewer visits left, and the full history exports as a CSV file.

What it does not do: points, memberships with recurring billing, a till, or bookings. If you need one of those, a point-of-sale or booking system is the better fit.

Free covers five active passes, with no payment card. After that, Starter is $4.99 a month for 100 active passes, Standard is $25 for 500, and Unlimited is $99, billed in US dollars. An active pass is one that still has visits left or a card partway to its reward; fully used passes stop counting. See pricing, or follow how to make a digital punch card for the setup step by step.

Questions people ask

What is the simplest loyalty program for a small business?

A punch card: one stamp per visit and a reward after a set number. Customers understand it without an explanation, and you can run it on paper, in your till, or as a digital card. Move to points or a membership only if a punch card cannot do what you need.

Should I use points or a punch card?

Use a punch card when most visits cost about the same, like a haircut, a wash or a lesson. Use points when what customers spend varies a lot from visit to visit, because a stamp treats a $20 visit and a $200 visit the same. Points usually need a till that counts spend.

How many stamps should a loyalty card have?

Multiply how often a good customer already visits by how far away the reward should be. A weekly customer and a reward about two months out gives a card of around eight. A customer who comes once a month needs a much shorter card, or a reward they reach in a year.

Can I start a loyalty program for free?

Yes. A paper card and a rubber stamp cost almost nothing. Returnpass is free for five active passes, with no payment card required, so you can try a digital stamp card or a prepaid package on a few regulars first.

How do I know if my loyalty program is working?

Write down how often your regulars come before you start. After two or three months, look at how many cards you handed out, how many reached the reward, and whether card holders now come more often than before. If almost nobody finishes, the card is too long or the reward too small.

Sources. Every figure above is linked to the study or report it came from, so you can check it rather than take our word for it.

Run one of these in about two minutes.

Returnpass gives you prepaid packages and stamp cards that live in your customer’s Apple Wallet. Five active passes are free, and no card is required to start.